Who doesn’t value English? Debunking myths about Mexican immigrants’ attitudes

 
Ethnic Mexican dress (iStock)
(iStock)
Share

Though migration from Mexico to the United States has slowed considerably in recent years, one persistent point of controversy embedded in the immigration reform debate relates to the use of Spanish in communities across America — and some new arrivals’ alleged unwillingness to learn and use English.

A 2012 study published in Social Science Quarterly, “Who Doesn’t Value English? Debunking Myths About Mexican Immigrants’ Attitudes Toward the English Language,” examined the importance that U.S. immigrants, particularly those from Mexico and Latin America, placed on learning English. The researchers, from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, the University of Texas at San Antonio and the University of Texas at Austin, analyzed data from the Survey of Texas Adults, which included 1,500 participants over the period 2003-2004. Respondents answered the question “How important is it that citizens be able to speak and understand English?” and provided additional demographic background.

Half of the respondents were Anglo and about a third of Mexican origin or descent. The average survey respondent was 35 years old with some college education but no degree; earned an annual income between $35,000 and $84,900; and leaned conservative politically.

Key study findings include:

  • Only 2% of all study participants, regardless of race or immigration status, claimed that learning English was “not too important” or “not important at all.”
  • “Spanish-dominant speakers place a high importance on speaking English, more so than do English speakers. While this might seem counterintuitive to some, it is easy to see how immigrants are constantly reminded of the problems they face in the workplace and the public sphere without English proficiency.”
  • Participants who chose to have their telephone interviews conducted in Spanish were three times more likely than Anglos to claim that English-language ability is “very important.” On average, women also valued learning English more than men did. Further, the researchers “found no evidence of income variations in the emphasis placed on English.”
  • Respondents ages 50 to 64 were nearly four times more likely than those younger or older to believe that English fluency is “very important.”
  • Texas-born Mexican-Americans and immigrants who have become American citizens placed less emphasis on learning English. “For the former, this may indicate a show of solidarity with immigrants who face increasing hostility in the media; for the latter, this may reflect an acknowledgment that in some areas with a high concentration of Spanish speakers, immigrants may be able to get by without English. It is important to note that both groups still overwhelmingly believe that English is ‘important,’ if not ‘very important.'”
  • This controversy should be seen in the context of a large body of prior research on assimilation in the United States, relating to generations of previous immigrant groups. “Studies suggest the second generation is increasingly proficient in English as their dominant language, and by the third generation, the grandchildren of immigrants are often no longer proficient in any language other than English.”

“Our findings raise serious questions about the accuracy of widespread claims by commentators, politicians and the general public alike that Mexican immigrants simply do not desire to learn English,” the researchers conclude.

Tags: campaign issue, Hispanic, Latino

    Writer: | Last updated: July 2, 2012

    Citation: Dowling, Julie A.; Ellison, Christopher G.; Leal, David L. "Who Doesn’t Value English? Debunking Myths About Mexican Immigrants’ Attitudes Toward the English Language," Social Science Quarterly, June 2012, Vol. 93, Issue 2, 356–378, doi: 10.1111/j.1540-6237.2012.00850.x.
     

    We welcome feedback. Please contact us here.